5 alive! Introducing my 2018 S3...

The Cardinal

For the love of cars
Joined
Jul 9, 2009
Messages
578
Reaction score
348
Points
63
Location
The West
As you might have guessed from the title, this thread is all about my fifth A3-series car – a 2018 S3 Sportback. In addition to other past cars, my A3 history comprises:

8P 2.0T quattro S Line Special Edition
8P S3
8P 2.0T SE high spec
8P 1.4T Sport

IMG-1109.jpg

IMG-2156.jpg

20190204_1343301_zpsoahg18na.jpg

20201022-094041.jpg


I passed my 40th birthday last year and, despite having lots of nice cars in the past, I've run fairly unremarkable cars since going out on a high with a supercharged Golf R32 and then being persuaded by the wife to buy our van in 2015/6. Like many a car fan of a certain age; I have gotten to the point in life where I have family commitments, life experiences, but also a bit more flexibility with finances – so I felt I’d now like to mark the big occasion with a special car, probably another S3 or Golf R. [City centre living doesn't permit something less sensible, sadly]

Yet somehow that big birthday and passed - and I didn’t press the button on a more tasty car. In fact, six months afterwards I got as far as ordering a new A3 8Y 1.5T as I'd been happy with my old 1.4T Sport and wanted something newer. But while this would have undoubtedly served us well as a family runabout, health issues in my family caused me to reflect again, to cancel the new car order and to look back towards a performance car instead. 100-mile round trips to support care are in sight for the years to come.

As I say, we do already have one fairly life-affirming vehicle in the house: Bus Blue. It's been a huge amount of fun to run as the main family wheels for the last 5 years, though the base van is now over 8 years old and we are now tending to do more miles in whatever car is run alongside it. So, in addition to meeting my needs by being more joyful, the next car also needed to accommodate the family, be good for long distance visits to (hopefully business miles, too, when post-pandemic normality resumes) and yet docile around town. I also want to own this long-term, as having our Bus has shown me just how beneficial this is to me because I really look after my vehciles... the van is still on original tyres, brake pads, discs etc at 55k miles.

20210411-115748.jpg


I did think about upgrading the new order to an 8Y S3. I'm sure it's a great car... but the styling hasn't grown on me and there are some details like standard privacy glass that put me off. Moreover, I think that the facelift 8V S3 is a bit of a high water mark - arguably it's just as good and more suitable for me than a Golf R. The facelift guarantees some things like 7-speed DSG, more standard equipment, re-tuning of the Haldex system and the option of some snazzy tech.

Plus, crucially, by sticking with the same bodyshell and interior I doubted that my wife would notice that the car had changed at all. :whistle2: (She didn't say anything when my old R32 was supercharged, but that's another story).

WP-20150916-002-1.jpg


I also decided that I didn't want to go down the PCP route and would prefer to dip into my savings for this new car, which ruled out an 8Y or equivalent Mk8 Golf R. Counting my previous A3 as part of the budget, I had up to £30k to play with and I knew this would get me into one of the latest facelift S3s.

Handily, a March 2018 model came up at a well-respected BMW / multi-marque specialist locally:

S3-6-1.jpg


It's a Daytona Sportback S-Stronic with the Technology Pack inc. virtual dash, folding mirrors, hill-hold assist, rear camera, wireless phone charging and some natty 10-spoke polished alloys. Being a facelift means it also gets some spec highlights including the Audi Sound System that I wanted, too. Mileage at sale was 21,811, it has a first Audi dealer service in its record and recent Potenza tyres all round. A service and MoT were due and the original handbook was missing, but it all seemed good on V-check, Cazana and Erwin - plus the service record is digital nowadays anyway.

So, it seems a decent spec and the understated colour akin to my old Golf R32 makes it likely to fit in with my needs - moreso than my old, very red, 8P S3. On balance, I'd have preferred to find one at an Audi franchise because of the warranty - but it made sense overall and so a deal was done. I found myself doing the handover last week:

20210413-103045.jpg


And here it is at home, its understated looks melting somewhat into the background - very much as I intended. I will get some better photos when I have the chance:

20210418-090339.jpg


I've always found that I can't properly assess a used car until it's been at home with me for a week or so, to clean it, drive it and digest the paperwork.

The history of the car is that it was PDI'd and had its first oil change service at 7,369 miles in 2019 with a main Audi franchise up north. Its next maintenance was the inspection service, rear discs and pads and MoT I negotiated with the supplying dealer at 21,811. Although it would have been nice to see an oil change in between, it still meets the longlife criteria.

However, it gets a bit confusing because this MMI screen suggests an inspection service was also done around 19k miles / August 2020:

20210417-121638.jpg


Erwin (digital service schedule) is only recording the PDI and first service at 7k miles in 2019, but I suspect another was done in 2020 without it being recorded digitally. This would tally with the fact that the car has 4 fairly recent tyres, all on about 6mm. I checked with the Audi franchise who did the first service and it wasn't them. Ho hum.

Condition

A good clean reveals completely original paint with no evidence of repairs anywhere, including the wheels. Sadly, I suspect my wife will trash said wheels and I know refurb options are limited to just 1-2 sessions on the lathe with these. They look good in the meantime though!

There's a little tar to the sides of the car and slight fine marking from car washing all over, but really it's very good bodywork. Inside the car, it's also perfect apart from a tiny repair to the driver's side bolster - again done as part of the sale. Unfortunately, I did notice this crack on the windscreen on the drive home from the dealer - it's in a really unfortunate location and could be a replacement issue, but either way it's being attended to at their expense next week:

20210413-145941.jpg


Done so far:

- Added a dateless 3x3 plate
- Remap; fairly conservative at 350hp / 335lb.ft - I've had enough of them over the years to be confident in going for one
- Added OEM accessory boot lip protector and boot tray; OEM rear door sill protectors ordered
- Added replica roof rails... hands up, this is facile fakery - though probably the only controversial thing I'll do to the car

To do next:

- Windscreen inspection next week - with a view to repair or replacement
- Haldex oil and brake fluid being changed next week
- Drive it and get some decent photos!

I've only managed to do around 80 miles in the car so far and it won't be rising quickly as we live a very local lifestyle and commute by bicycle. The upside being that driving is always something to look forward to, usually longer-distance / for fun and so the overall annual miles are kept low - probably 4-5,000 per year, unless business miles take off again or care visits become needed a lot more.

Within those limitations, I'll just say that this new S3 is a fine, fine car on first acquaintance - feeling mainly like my old 8P S3 in the body of my last 8V A3. The combination of S-Tronic 'box and Hill Hold make it really easy to use and I just love shifting manually for those up-change exhaust parps. I am going to be very boring and say that the performance potential of this car won't be used very often... but I've tested it and can assure you it's there (traction control kicks in at full throttle even at high speeds, unless you disable it!). It's certainly more usable than my old and admittedly lower-order supercharged R32 or tuned Fiat Coupe 20V Turbo, both of which ran slightly higher peak horsepower figures. But it's mostly "more usable" in the sense that it only slightly less comfortable than the old A3 and still has a comfy interior, decent boot etc.

I'll keep the thread updated as things develop...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, Audi Bairn, pburv and 5 others
That’s a nice car. Didn’t realise 18 plates we’re going for around £30k, might need to look at selling mine.
Is there any reason why some pics have roof rails and other don’t?
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Cardinal
Thank you. It was less than £30k - that was just my top budget! The roof rails are my add-on... see post for details.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Audi Bairn and AlS3BE
Thank you. It was less than £30k - that was just my top budget! The roof rails are my add-on... see post for details.
Me skim reading again.
Used to think cars with rails look out of place till I got mine with roof rails. Now all a3/s3 look odd to me without them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Audi Bairn
Aftermarket rails, god I hope these arent the stick on ones......
 
Ha! Yes, they are... :redface: I'm undecided TBH, I had them left over from before. I don't want to turn this into a roof rails thread, but obviously they won't be left on when I'm done with the car.
 
I enjoyed the read and the pics please do keep the thread updated always interested to see what fellow 8v S3 owners
are doing with there cars :icon thumright:
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Cardinal and Sandra
Lovely write up & choice of vehicle but I am biased. This is exactly why the wife & I bought ours being 'easy to drive" plus an S3 Sportback ticked all our other boxes as it has for yourself.
I'm sure you're aware but get the Haldex pump removed & gauze cleaned when having the oil changed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Cardinal
Lovely write up & choice of vehicle but I am biased. This is exactly why the wife & I bought ours being 'easy to drive" plus an S3 Sportback ticked all our other boxes as it has for yourself.
I'm sure you're aware but get the Haldex pump removed & gauze cleaned when having the oil changed.

Thanks - it's with my trusted VAG indie on Monday to have the Haldex oil done and it was reassuring that they already knew about the gauze clean.
 
Thanks - it's with my trusted VAG indie on Monday to have the Haldex oil done and it was reassuring that they already knew about the gauze clean
I'am considering getting my Haldex oil change and gauze clean done early i'am on just under 18k is it worth getting done yet ?
 
If it's approaching 3 years old, I'd do it. I have seen plenty of stories about clogged units at low age / miles, though also plenty that have been fine on inspection.
 
If it's approaching 3 years old, I'd do it. I have seen plenty of stories about clogged units at low age / miles, though also plenty that have been fine on inspection.
It was 2 year old in march just gone . Going to look into having it done sometime this year .
 
Ha! Yes, they are... :redface: I'm undecided TBH, I had them left over from before. I don't want to turn this into a roof rails thread, but obviously they won't be left on when I'm done with the car.
I would never ever fit rails unless they bolted to the roof, I've been asked & point bluntly refused, imagine if the bonding fails, it then becomes a javelin & the repercussions of that would change yours & possibly end someone or number of people's lives, its a bad move imho & a disaster waiting to happen.

Having fitted a few, the rail width is very narrow, any 3m, bonding you use is just nowhere near enough to have peace of mind.

You have to seriously think about what happens if it comes of on a motorway or the like.

Your car, your choice, but its madness tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8YARWY and The Cardinal
Various commitments and the lack of an exotic setting have prevented me from taking some pics of the S3, but I have been able to do the following:

- Haldex oil and brake fluid replaced
- Checked tracking (no adjustment necessary)
- Checked whether any upgrades / functions were available via Carista (couldn't find any; assume it was due to spec already having it all)
- OEM accessory boot liner added from old A3 and new boot lip protection film applied
- OEM rear door sill protectors added... can't believe they aren't standard
- c.350hp remap done
- Started removing some tar and mildly polishing some panels
- Windscreen chip repaired professionally
- Removed those roof rails I trialled :whistle2:

I've covered just under 200 miles since picking up the car, including its first run over to check on my parents. Fuel economy on mundane weekend runabout duties is around 25mpg, but I thought 42mpg on the longer run was pretty good.

I've driven more miles with the map than not, so can't really say much about it to be honest. I find that the traction control is very aggressive on full throttle unless turned off, including at higher speeds.

It's a lovely car overall, though. I'm very impressed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, springer and rashu786
Various commitments and the lack of an exotic setting have prevented me from taking some pics of the S3, but I have been able to do the following:

- Haldex oil and brake fluid replaced
- Checked tracking (no adjustment necessary)
- Checked whether any upgrades / functions were available via Carista (couldn't find any; assume it was due to spec already having it all)
- OEM accessory boot liner added from old A3 and new boot lip protection film applied
- OEM rear door sill protectors added... can't believe they aren't standard
- c.350hp remap done
- Started removing some tar and mildly polishing some panels
- Windscreen chip repaired professionally
- Removed those roof rails I trialled :whistle2:

I've covered just under 200 miles since picking up the car, including its first run over to check on my parents. Fuel economy on mundane weekend runabout duties is around 25mpg, but I thought 42mpg on the longer run was pretty good.

I've driven more miles with the map than not, so can't really say much about it to be honest. I find that the traction control is very aggressive on full throttle unless turned off, including at higher speeds.

It's a lovely car overall, though. I'm very impressed.
Hi do you have the part number for the door sills I could do with someone on my rears
 
The part number is 8V4853557A for the sill trims. I bought them from Audi Oldenburg after otherwise finding only listings for left hand parts - sadly their price has gone up by around 20% since ordering 2 weeks ago!
 
Before escaping to the country this weekend, I managed to put the car through its paces in between kids' sporting activities. Disengaging the traction control seems to be the only way to get full power and I managed to get the rear wheels to slip on the best test I know for this sort of car: a full throttle launch on an off-camber sliproad incline, while turning sharply to exit a junction. Few cars I know do it better than this S-Tronic equipped S3.

Thankfully the car seems to attract little road warrior attention, though people do seem to know what it is. Perhaps the 718 Cayman S that pulled up alongside me at some lights could sense that I was primed in "S" mode with the traction control off, because we both made away from the light change onto a very empty dual carriageway ahead with remarkable restraint. :laughing: I'm happy with this sort of calmness, though - it suits me and the car.

Driving us as a family of four to visit relatives in the country for an al fresco lunch also reminded me of how similar this new S3 is to my last, 2010 S3 S-Tronic.

20210502-141337.jpg


It's a supremely under-stressed car in these conditions - I barely have to feather the accelerator or get involved in gear-changing to make rapid but very relaxed progress. There was a sharp intake of breath at least once when making a rare overtake, but the 39mpg overall for the 120-miler is a better illustration of how it's driven. The kids found the ride a little jiggly in the back over some of Salisbury Plain's roads, but the low-speed ride and cabin's plushness offsets that I think.

Apart from lower fuel economy and more shouty Brilliant Red colour, this is exactly how I remember my 2010 S3. A downsized luxury express, excelling at mild-mannered distance covering - but with fuller entertainment being just a temptation away.

While the last 10 years see a similar package for the S3, that's not the case for all other cars. My father-in-law wants to update his Mk7 Golf 2.0 TDI 150 GT for something ULEZ-compliant, as they have a house in London too. I was shocked to see how few manual, mid-range diesel Golfs and A3s there now are in the 0-3 year age bracket - it feels like they were once a default choice, but there are barely a handful of each now on Autotrader.

Finally, a note on the registration plate. TOT 1 was the number gracing my first car... a blue and red plastic ride-on toy c.1981. The real TOT 1 seems to be registered to a Range Rover somewhere, though I'm quite satisfied with the 3 x 3 I picked up earlier this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bells, Jcbmally, NevMan and 1 other person
The inevitable happened in the last few weeks - a wheel met the chunky kerb outside our house, while the car was being driven by my wife. I gave up making a big deal about this sort of thing a very long time ago and don't even mention it to my wife... I suppose it's just a small thing in the scheme of life, but my secret OCD persona finds it a bit annoying all the same!

20210522-184809.jpg


After many years of this, however, I am one step ahead: :wink:

20210517-135024.jpg


It's a refurbished original wheel. I'll swap this over and then get the original refurb'd - which will then be ready for the next repeat offence!!! I'm just not sure whether to order a new matching Pirelli P Zero Nero GT, or whether to swap over the original tyre? The original tyre is on c.6mm, whereas a new one is 8mm-ish. Consulting the internet indicates that a slight wear difference will be ok - and it would be convenient to be able to swap myself without visiting a tyre fitter every time.

The next job was to tackle what looked like a few tiny splatters of white paint on the driver's seat. I did this by using a flat blade knife and olive oil:

20210522-184544.jpg


The spots were quite hard to see anyway, but I'm quite chuffed with the results:

20210522-185024.jpg


I suspect that the car was driven a lot by someone wearing high heels, due to some minor carpet wear under the brake pedal - now looking a lot better after a session on it today with fabric cleaner and a damp microfibre cloth:

20210522-184619.jpg


Despite minor cosmetic blemishes being a fact of life where we live, I'm having a bit of a dither about whether to get a small car to run alongside the S3. This would be mainly for my wife, who uses the S3 to do local errands and will increasingly do so in the future. Our van is going to be affected by a local ULEZ-type zone, which means it effectively can't be used as our second vehicle (and I may store it in a local lock-up). Decisions, decisions.

In the meantime, we've got some family road trip miles coming up. Maybe I'll fit the new wheel in preparation for that... :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, Mr Freeze, NevMan and 2 others
New wheel and tyre on:

20210528-105012.jpg


Pirelli PZero Nero GT are a new tyre to me. Matching one with the four already on the car cost a reasonable £88 fitted. The existing (scratched) wheel will be re-finished once I get some time to make arrangements.

Now though, we're about to set off on a 400-mile trip with four up and luggage... though depending on how much luggage, I may cave in and take the van instead!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, springer and Mr Freeze
The inevitable happened in the last few weeks - a wheel met the chunky kerb outside our house, while the car was being driven by my wife. I gave up making a big deal about this sort of thing a very long time ago and don't even mention it to my wife... I suppose it's just a small thing in the scheme of life, but my secret OCD persona finds it a bit annoying all the same!

20210522-184809.jpg


After many years of this, however, I am one step ahead: :wink:

20210517-135024.jpg


It's a refurbished original wheel. I'll swap this over and then get the original refurb'd - which will then be ready for the next repeat offence!!! I'm just not sure whether to order a new matching Pirelli P Zero Nero GT, or whether to swap over the original tyre? The original tyre is on c.6mm, whereas a new one is 8mm-ish. Consulting the internet indicates that a slight wear difference will be ok - and it would be convenient to be able to swap myself without visiting a tyre fitter every time.

The next job was to tackle what looked like a few tiny splatters of white paint on the driver's seat. I did this by using a flat blade knife and olive oil:

20210522-184544.jpg


The spots were quite hard to see anyway, but I'm quite chuffed with the results:

20210522-185024.jpg


I suspect that the car was driven a lot by someone wearing high heels, due to some minor carpet wear under the brake pedal - now looking a lot better after a session on it today with fabric cleaner and a damp microfibre cloth:

20210522-184619.jpg


Despite minor cosmetic blemishes being a fact of life where we live, I'm having a bit of a dither about whether to get a small car to run alongside the S3. This would be mainly for my wife, who uses the S3 to do local errands and will increasingly do so in the future. Our van is going to be affected by a local ULEZ-type zone, which means it effectively can't be used as our second vehicle (and I may store it in a local lock-up). Decisions, decisions.

In the meantime, we've got some family road trip miles coming up. Maybe I'll fit the new wheel in preparation for that... :)
Good idea having a spare rim i'am considering doing the same for when the inevitable happens .
Keep the updates coming :icon thumright:
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Cardinal
Nice story mate, 18 plate S3 8V, no S3 better before or after IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Freeze and The Cardinal
Totally agree and I went and bought a brand new 19 plate :crying:
Still a few nice 18plates around and they are holding their money. You can always go back mate :yes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Freeze
The inevitable happened in the last few weeks - a wheel met the chunky kerb outside our house, while the car was being driven by my wife. I gave up making a big deal about this sort of thing a very long time ago and don't even mention it to my wife... I suppose it's just a small thing in the scheme of life, but my secret OCD persona finds it a bit annoying all the same!

20210522-184809.jpg


After many years of this, however, I am one step ahead: :wink:

20210517-135024.jpg


It's a refurbished original wheel. I'll swap this over and then get the original refurb'd - which will then be ready for the next repeat offence!!! I'm just not sure whether to order a new matching Pirelli P Zero Nero GT, or whether to swap over the original tyre? The original tyre is on c.6mm, whereas a new one is 8mm-ish. Consulting the internet indicates that a slight wear difference will be ok - and it would be convenient to be able to swap myself without visiting a tyre fitter every time.

The next job was to tackle what looked like a few tiny splatters of white paint on the driver's seat. I did this by using a flat blade knife and olive oil:

20210522-184544.jpg


The spots were quite hard to see anyway, but I'm quite chuffed with the results:

20210522-185024.jpg


I suspect that the car was driven a lot by someone wearing high heels, due to some minor carpet wear under the brake pedal - now looking a lot better after a session on it today with fabric cleaner and a damp microfibre cloth:

20210522-184619.jpg


Despite minor cosmetic blemishes being a fact of life where we live, I'm having a bit of a dither about whether to get a small car to run alongside the S3. This would be mainly for my wife, who uses the S3 to do local errands and will increasingly do so in the future. Our van is going to be affected by a local ULEZ-type zone, which means it effectively can't be used as our second vehicle (and I may store it in a local lock-up). Decisions, decisions.

In the meantime, we've got some family road trip miles coming up. Maybe I'll fit the new wheel in preparation for that... :)
The inevitable happened today my wife curbed the front drivers side wheel :cry: so I need to get another alloy as I don't want the car off the road for a couple of days ( pain in the a... not having a spare wheel ) where did you get your alloy from if you don't mind me asking
 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, The Cardinal and AlS3BE
I found the part number for the wheel and then sourced it on Ebay. The going rate for a used, scuffed wheel was around £180.

I thought I'd buy one of these and then have it refurbished. Handily, an already refurbished wheel came up at £280 - so I bought that. The tyre was a further £88.

£368 all-in is not cheap (and that's before I refurbish the one just scuffed), but it's the price I pay for maintaining a nice car in my family / city centre circumstances.

For the time being, it's also a lot cheaper than running a sacrificial city car alongside the S3 and van - although this may well be on the agenda if I can find a garage for the van.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally
I've done quite a few more miles recently (for me, at least). Here's the trip computer reading for a first leg drive to York this week:

20210708-092933.jpg


I'm admittedly a sedate driver when covering distance with work - 65mph on cruise control is what I've found works best for me over 10 years of UK-wide business trips. That figure turned out to be 47.5mpg on a brim-to-brim basis, which I think is still impressive. I've used dozens of personal and hire cars over the same journey with this style of driving: 2008 Golf R32 (35mpg), 2014 Astra 1.6 (41mpg), 2006 A3 2.0T & 2008 Golf GTI (41mpg), 2012 Volvo V60 D5 (61mpg), 2015 Golf 1.4 ACT (63mpg), 2018 Lexus CT200h (71mpg) and *drumroll* a 2015 Nissan Qashqai 1.5 DCi (73mpg).

Sadly, I ended up doing the return leg on the same day due to my parents having another emergency - I set out at 5am from home and then had to set off unexpectedly from York again at 8pm after a full day's business. My goodness that was a long one. :(

But, of course, I've had some more enjoyable drives recently as well. :) In all of this, I am finding the S3 to be superb and I am the 7-speed DSG 'box is one of the best bits. It's an outstandingly capable car over distances, though all the long distance driving now makes it feel totally overkill when I use it locally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, JohnM100, Mr Freeze and 1 other person
I'm still mighty impressed with the fuel figures that can be achieved from a FL S3, bonkers from a performance orientated hot hatch. Totally agree with you regarding the DSG box, the wife & I love our :s3addict:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, Mr Freeze and NevMan
I've done quite a few more miles recently (for me, at least). Here's the trip computer reading for a first leg drive to York this week:

20210708-092933.jpg


I'm admittedly a sedate driver when covering distance with work - 65mph on cruise control is what I've found works best for me over 10 years of UK-wide business trips. That figure turned out to be 47.5mpg on a brim-to-brim basis, which I think is still impressive. I've used dozens of personal and hire cars over the same journey with this style of driving: 2008 Golf R32 (35mpg), 2014 Astra 1.6 (41mpg), 2006 A3 2.0T & 2008 Golf GTI (41mpg), 2012 Volvo V60 D5 (61mpg), 2015 Golf 1.4 ACT (63mpg), 2018 Lexus CT200h (71mpg) and *drumroll* a 2015 Nissan Qashqai 1.5 DCi (73mpg).

Sadly, I ended up doing the return leg on the same day due to my parents having another emergency - I set out at 5am from home and then had to set off unexpectedly from York again at 8pm after a full day's business. My goodness that was a long one. :(

But, of course, I've had some more enjoyable drives recently as well. :) In all of this, I am finding the S3 to be superb and I am the 7-speed DSG 'box is one of the best bits. It's an outstandingly capable car over distances, though all the long distance driving now makes it feel totally overkill when I use it locally.
I got 47.6 MPG in my 2019 S3 recently from Manchester to Watford and is by far the best MPG I've had in nearly 2 and half years of owning it .
We have a week away in Dorset coming up so I will try and beat it :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally
The most recent (positive) development is that I've recently started keeping the S3 in a local underground garage that I'm renting a space in. It's a long story, prompted by semi-retiring our van and having bought a Skoda Fabia for local family duties - and it has the side benefit of me now being the S3's main driver, hopefully meaning fewer kerbings to the wheels. This arrangement may or may not persist as I'm really looking to store the van (too big for most lockups), but at least I get to feel like a Bond baddie for now. ;)

20210819-160118.jpg


In less pleasant news... I thought that the traction issues I'd intermittently experienced were sorted when I changed the Haldex oil, but some recent drives in rain have had the car spinning its wheels when setting off from junctions etc. I decided to do some test drives with a bit more commitment from standing starts in the dry as well, with the traction control off - and I have also been getting wheelspin in these circumstances. The traction control light also comes on a lot when driving down country roads with some gusto.

I booked it into the garage I bought it from for inspection as it came with a 3-month warranty, which I'm now outside of, but I thought I'd give them a go. I told them this was my fourth 4WD VAG and none of them behaved like this. They had it for the day and agreed it's losing traction as I'd described. Nonetheless, there are no fault codes showing and they said their opinion (based on seeing several cars with Haldex issues) was that this was mainly due to the tyres. They did a 4-wheel alignment, which they said was slightly out and recommended I got a set of more focused tyres like Michelin Pilot Sports.

The current tyres are matching P Zero Nero GTs with c.5-6mm on them - while they aren't the best I don't personally feel that these are the issue. The supplying garage deal with performance cars from Ferrari downwards and seem like a reasonable outfit, but I don't think I'm going to get anywhere with them especially as I'm out of warranty.

So, I am now mulling whether it's better for me just to hand it over to my trusted VAG indy with a view to replacing the most likely culprit, the Haldex pump, at c.£300? This is cheaper than four tyres anyway!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally
The car's now booked-in for this to be sorted with my usual indy specialist - but it won't be until mid-September as they're so busy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally
Time for a little update.

Firstly, I swapped to this garage in late August:

20210902-074114.jpg


It's not as nice as the underground car park space I previously had... and it certainly won't fit our van in it (which is what I would really like) - but it's a local authority tenancy meaning a fair price and I'm very unlikely to be turfed-out.

The size looked pretty good empty, so I took the garage on first inspection. As you can see here, though, it's a pretty tight squeeze!

20210918-114004.jpg

20210918-113902.jpg


I've managed to perfect the art of reversing into the space so that I can get out, although not before I unfortunately nicked an alloy on strange flap just a few centimetres from the floor on the side of the door. I don't fancy it without parking sensors and the reverse camera - those guide-lines are invaluable here. I've also carpeted a few places to avoid marking the bodywork:

20210918-113942.jpg

20210918-113948.jpg


So, the S3 is now mainly tucked-up in its snug garage while the van and new Fabia live outside the house. Although I am still looking to store the van, it's quite nice to keep the S3 off the street and thereby avoid the small scuffs that often come from city life.

Fixing the Haldex

As documented in another thread, the traction / AWD issues I've previously mentioned took an unexpected turn. This is not an outcome I've seen reported elsewhere online.

20210917-133323.jpg


Firstly, a proper VCDS scan did show a traction fault code. I haven't checked which the code was, but it's not one that came up via my Carista app and that's worth noting in itself. The mechanic removed the original Haldex pump and found it to be working, though with shards of metal and gunk present. I guess this is what many other people are finding and, following a clean / new oil / reset this is usually enough to solve the issue.

[I should add that my Haldex oil was changed 2,500 miles ago by the same people...]

This might normally have been enough to restore satisfactory performance. However, in my case, there was apparently another issue.

I'm told that the second issue was a manufacturing defect in the Haldex unit itself - where several of the oil reservoir chambers were insufficiently machined and this meant that the unit created insufficient pressure. The mechanic's view was that this was present at the time of manufacture and that the rear drive had quite probably never given full torque to the rear from new.
scratchchin


The solution was to shorten the drain plug to create more space for the oil flow. I was instructed to tell whoever does the next Haldex oil change to make the same adaptation to the drain plug. I'm a little confused about this and it seems slightly bodge-ish. Nonetheless, it's worked!

Finally, the Haldex pump was replaced as it was found to be underperforming - which is likely a consequence of the first issue.

Just... wow. The transformation of the driving experience is immense. I challenge anyone to drive one of these cars in the state mine was in and then not to notice a *massive* improvement. Even at very low speeds there's an huge difference, while on the open road / out of bends etc it's nothing short of breathtaking now that full torque is being put down by all 4 wheels. Now I know why I persisted in solving this and it reminds me how well-suited these VAG 4WD hatches can be for me and my preferences.

I drove the car for 5 months and 2,500 miles in its pre-fixed state. To think that the first owner probably drove 22,000 miles like that seems amazing to me.

I suppose the final bill was somewhat steeper than I'd like, caused by more investigate labour and two flushes of the Haldex fluid - but right now it seems worth it.

20210917-122953.jpg

20210917-122945.jpg


The S3 is in its 8th month with me and has done an average of 465 miles in each of those - mainly family trips, business miles and visiting my parents.

I admit that I did look at selling up recently because that new Fabia and our trusty old van would cover many of our needs (plus used prices remain strong enough for me to have sold at a profit until the last few days). However, it's only fair to point out that buying this S3 and the Fabia still cost me less than a new 8Y S3. The enjoyment and flexibility I get from having this mini fleet is also something I value.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally, Harvey, K96 and 1 other person
Time for a little update.

Firstly, I swapped to this garage in late August:

20210902-074114.jpg


It's not as nice as the underground car park space I previously had... and it certainly won't fit our van in it (which is what I would really like) - but it's a local authority tenancy meaning a fair price and I'm very unlikely to be turfed-out.

The size looked pretty good empty, so I took the garage on first inspection. As you can see here, though, it's a pretty tight squeeze!

20210918-114004.jpg

20210918-113902.jpg


I've managed to perfect the art of reversing into the space so that I can get out, although not before I unfortunately nicked an alloy on strange flap just a few centimetres from the floor on the side of the door. I don't fancy it without parking sensors and the reverse camera - those guide-lines are invaluable here. I've also carpeted a few places to avoid marking the bodywork:

20210918-113942.jpg

20210918-113948.jpg


So, the S3 is now mainly tucked-up in its snug garage while the van and new Fabia live outside the house. Although I am still looking to store the van, it's quite nice to keep the S3 off the street and thereby avoid the small scuffs that often come from city life.

Fixing the Haldex

As documented in another thread, the traction / AWD issues I've previously mentioned took an unexpected turn. This is not an outcome I've seen reported elsewhere online.

20210917-133323.jpg


Firstly, a proper VCDS scan did show a traction fault code. I haven't checked which the code was, but it's not one that came up via my Carista app and that's worth noting in itself. The mechanic removed the original Haldex pump and found it to be working, though with shards of metal and gunk present. I guess this is what many other people are finding and, following a clean / new oil / reset this is usually enough to solve the issue.

[I should add that my Haldex oil was changed 2,500 miles ago by the same people...]

This might normally have been enough to restore satisfactory performance. However, in my case, there was apparently another issue.

I'm told that the second issue was a manufacturing defect in the Haldex unit itself - where several of the oil reservoir chambers were insufficiently machined and this meant that the unit created insufficient pressure. The mechanic's view was that this was present at the time of manufacture and that the rear drive had quite probably never given full torque to the rear from new.
scratchchin


The solution was to shorten the drain plug to create more space for the oil flow. I was instructed to tell whoever does the next Haldex oil change to make the same adaptation to the drain plug. I'm a little confused about this and it seems slightly bodge-ish. Nonetheless, it's worked!

Finally, the Haldex pump was replaced as it was found to be underperforming - which is likely a consequence of the first issue.

Just... wow. The transformation of the driving experience is immense. I challenge anyone to drive one of these cars in the state mine was in and then not to notice a *massive* improvement. Even at very low speeds there's an huge difference, while on the open road / out of bends etc it's nothing short of breathtaking now that full torque is being put down by all 4 wheels. Now I know why I persisted in solving this and it reminds me how well-suited these VAG 4WD hatches can be for me and my preferences.

I drove the car for 5 months and 2,500 miles in its pre-fixed state. To think that the first owner probably drove 22,000 miles like that seems amazing to me.

I suppose the final bill was somewhat steeper than I'd like, caused by more investigate labour and two flushes of the Haldex fluid - but right now it seems worth it.

20210917-122953.jpg

20210917-122945.jpg


The S3 is in its 8th month with me and has done an average of 465 miles in each of those - mainly family trips, business miles and visiting my parents.

I admit that I did look at selling up recently because that new Fabia and our trusty old van would cover many of our needs (plus used prices remain strong enough for me to have sold at a profit until the last few days). However, it's only fair to point out that buying this S3 and the Fabia still cost me less than a new 8Y S3. The enjoyment and flexibility I get from having this mini fleet is also something I value.
Another great update/read as always . Where do you stand at the moment with the S3 on selling v keeping .

I like yourself have thought about selling my S3 recently while the prices are high
 
To be honest, I can justify either selling or keeping.

When I bought the S3, it was going to be run alongside our van as the only car. However, our daughter has since started at a new school the other side of town and it looks like our son could be headed down a similar route - these come with a commitment to pick-ups from school on some weekday evenings and most weekends. For my son, it could even be daily. My wife has also started doing evening sports and our son now has a programme of weekend rugby.

None of our original needs have changed, either. We don’t drive to work, but I drive nationwide on business and support my parents who are a 110-mile round trip away.

I’ve said to my wife that what we need for all this is two cars. What we had until recently was the S3 and van.

All our needs could be covered by that duo, but soon we will have a ULEZ-type zone very close to the house and all these journeys go through it. The new driving is urban and is therefore harsh on two lovely, distinctive vehicles - maintaining gleaming bodywork, polished alloys, interior etc becomes a running job.

All of this led me to buy a 2017 Fabia 1.2 110 DSG over the summer. It’s been a resounding hit with my wife and for the new uses above.

So much so, that it made me seriously look into selling the S3. I have worked and saved hard so that the van, Fabia & S3 are owned outright. This means I have a lot of capital tied up in them, but selling one makes little difference to ongoing costs. The van in particular has a lot of sentimental value to the wife and kids.

I was intending to garage the van, but I haven’t found anything suitable close-by and that’s why the S3 is living in the lockup. (We live in a controlled parking zone - I could keep all 3 vehicles on the street, but that feels a bit antisocial to our neighbours.)

Overall, it feels like a head/ heart thing. I’ve decided for now to continue running 3 vehicles and keep an eye on how well it suits us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jcbmally

Similar threads

Replies
27
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
929
Gordo77
G
Replies
8
Views
5K
Replies
0
Views
540