New S-Tronic 'box being fitted.

sixpot

Registered User
Joined
Jul 7, 2014
Messages
151
Reaction score
51
Points
28
Location
NULL
My S4 has suffered some of the symptoms that other owners were seeing, mainly being rough down-shifts into gears 2 and 1, pulsing at low speeds (like a type of kangarooing) and the occasional hesitance selecting reverse gear. (amongst other things....)
This spoilt what was otherwise a superb drive, so I decided to take the car into Audi for them to have a look.
At this point I should state the car has a third party extended warranty through AutoTrust, (Formula X warranty) which was initially taken out as part of the deal when I purchased the car used, through a BMW main dealer.
The warranty was renewed at the end of the initial 3 month period of cover. (rough cost £565/year with a claim limit up to the value of the car (agreed before taking out policy) and no excess/number of claim limits)
Audi had the car and couldn't find a fault (surprise surprise!) as no fault codes had been logged, what they did find however was a completely collapsed vacuum hose from the engine, which was thought to be causing the gearbox issue, but after renewing the pipe it made no difference! They test drove the car and found nothing untoward!!!
Disappointed with the result, I continued to search for someone willing to do more than just plug a computer in, and after speaking to a friend in the trade, he recommended me a local gearbox specialist, whom agreed to take the job on.
Fast forward a few weeks, and the warranty company agreed to a complete gearbox replacement, after an engineer from them had test-drove the car and agreed it was faulty. RESULT!
A brand new gearbox was ordered up from Audi in Germany, and last week it turned up, after only a 6 day lead time.




Today (Monday) the car was booked in, and as we speak, the old 'box is out, and tomorrow the new 'box will be fitted.
Here is a copy of the invoice (trade prices) that the warranty company is going to receive...


Hopefully, the car will be completely different to drive, when I get it back, and I am lucky to have the fault covered by the warranty!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruairi83, GAS MONKEY, xpoweruk and 2 others
Result, I usually say to people that most warranties aren't worth the paper they are written on, it seems in this case they have come through and hopefully the car should be back to normal. Fairly poor though that these boxes seem to be failing at such low mileages.
I can see why VAG seem to be going away from the DSG boxes in favour of the new generation 8 speed Tiptronics on their more powerful cars.
 
Amazing and so is S-Tronic till it goes wrong .

Trouble is when an S-Tronic car reaches a low value after many years and the gearbox is faulty what then .
 
  • Like
Reactions: sixpot
Yes, great labour rate and incredible accuracy - 10.1 hours!
 
  • Like
Reactions: sixpot
Is this S-Tronic issue only happening with S4's? (asking as I have a 2009 2.0 petrol S-tronic with 102k miles on)
 
With the new box fitted, how likely is it to fail again in the future? Whats the issue with these failing and was that issue ever rectified by Audi on revised boxes?
 
Was your gear changes as seamless as it was when you first drove your car.

I had a new dual mass flywheel assembly fitted onto my 2013 model after a timing chain was replaced. I had a chance to test drive it and found that a sudden hard knock was felt when you selected spiritedly hard from 2 to 3.
 
Good thing you had a warranty and they agreed to come through.
But please, do all of us a favor and start buying cars with proper boxes. It's the gazillionth time I hear of a DSG failure. The new B9 2.0Tfsi quattro no longer comes with a manual box... :frown new: what you gonna do? That's right, pay Audi £10k for a £5-15k car when this pos box inevitably breaks.
 
Good thing you had a warranty and they agreed to come through.
But please, do all of us a favor and start buying cars with proper boxes. It's the gazillionth time I hear of a DSG failure. The new B9 2.0Tfsi quattro no longer comes with a manual box... :frown new: what you gonna do? That's right, pay Audi £10k for a £5-15k car when this pos box inevitably breaks.

Or take out a 3rd party warranty such as the OP and hope that they cover such repairs...
 
I had similar problems with my 2009 3.0TDI A5 Cabriolet. Audi specialist where I bought it from "couldn't find the fault" but admitted it may have one. They had it a total of 3 x 1 week periods over the 10 weeks I owned it. Eventually they agreed to buy it back from me